Does Michael Vick Deserve a Second Chance?

Michael Vick is back home in Hampton, Va., after being released from prison yesterday. The disgraced and supposedly penniless former NFL star will begin work at one of W.M. Jordan Co.’s 40 commercial construction sites earning $10 an hour as a general laborer. The company’s president, John R. Lawson, is an ‘75 grad and a member of the Virginia Tech Board of Visitors. Clearly he believes that Vick deserves a second chance, as do I.

Here’s the thing that really bothers me: Michael Vick did more time in prison, 19 months, for killing pitbulls, than St. Louis Rams defensive lineman Leonard Little did for killing a woman in 1998 while driving drunk. Little served 90 days in jail, four years probation and 1,000 hours of community service… He KILLED a woman. A mother. A wife. A 15-year-old boy lost his mom and a husband, who had already lost a daughter to a car accident lost his wife. And all Little got was 90 days in jail.

The NFL suspended him for eight games. Vick has already missed two full seasons and could very well get a suspension from current no-nonsense commissioner Roger Goodell, but he has said that he will not even meet with Vick until the former star’s home confinement is completely on July 20.

Following Little’s 90 days in jail, he said that he would never forget what he had done. Apparently he did because in 2004 he was arrested for driving drunk and speeding. He failed three sobriety tests, but somehow the charges were dismissed and he walked away with a mere speeding charge. Unbelievable.

So, what can we take from this? That killing a dog, while unthinkable and detestable, is a greater crime in our society than killing a human being. Some will argue that in Little’s case he didn’t intentionally mean to kill someone. Bullocks! He got in the car while drunk and he should be responsible for his actions. In my opinion, Little deserved more jail time than Vick and so does Dante Stallworth of the New Orleans Saints, who faces DUI manslaughter charged after killing a man while driving drunk. And now for the head-shaking bit of news from Yahoo! Sports, according to Jason Cole’s article Stallworth may get break on manslaughter charge:

Stallworth, who is scheduled to be arraigned Thursday, may still have to serve time in jail and reach a civil settlement with the family of Mario Reyes, who was killed when Stallworth hit him in the early morning hours of March 14. However, Stallworth’s jail time could be only a matter of two or three months rather than the possibility of up to 15 years in prison under state law, two NFL sources said this week. Beyond that, Stallworth could play this season, one of the sources said.

Only a matter of two or three months? He could play this season? For killing a man? Am I the only one outraged by this? Thankfully I’m not alone , but it seems like we’re in the minority. Kill a man and you can be out of jail in 2-3 months and play that season. Kill pitbulls and go to prison (not jail, there is a difference) and serve nearly two years and miss 2-3 seasons. Yeah, America, our priorities are completely out of whack. Stallworth should be suspended for the season, at least!

The other things that bothers me about this whole thing is that PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) says Vick doesn’t deserve another shot at the NFL until he passes a psychological evaluation. Really? Really, PETA? Your whack job zealots go around throwing blood on people … perhaps you need to undergo psychological evaluations before you start mandating who can and cannot return to their job after paying their debt to society as prescribed by their sentence.

What Vick did was horrible and as a dog lover I do not condone what he did. But he paid his debt to society. He paid more for his crime than his peers did or will for their crimes of killing a human being. Vick deserves a second chance and I can’t wait to see him get his life together, show repentence and then get back on the field.

Popularity: 14% [?]

7 Responses to “Does Michael Vick Deserve a Second Chance?”

  1. Dave says:

    Gary,
    I’ve said since the stories resurfaced about Vick getting out of jail that the one man who was going to have just as bad a time of it as him is Leonard Little. I totally agree with you.

    It’s amazing to me that the very people who scream and yell about due process and equal justice for everyone are now the ones screaming that MV7 has no business just waltzing back into his former life.

    I don’t think anyone can honestly expect him to come out of the other side of this thing the same as he was before. It’s one thing for a person to say that he or she has changed. It’s something else for a person the caliber of Tony Dungy to say it, which he did after his recent meeting with Vick.

    I say if he ever gets caught for something like this again, throw the full force of the law at him. But until then, don’t treat him like he’s going pitbull shopping every time he leaves his house.

    Good luck, Michael. I, for one, hope it works out for you.

  2. Tom says:

    Killed a dog? ha. How about dogs, plural? Also much much more. Was an example made of him? yes. Does he deserve everything coming to him? yes. 2nd chance in the NFL? prob.

  3. ChemHokie says:

    Michael Vick has paid his debt to society–and more. MV1 deserves another chance int he NFL.

  4. Barry Wall, Ed.D. says:

    MV has paid his dues to society. He grew up with some thugs and he acted in like manner by doing this. But, he paid the price like all others that go to jail.

    He is still a human being and deserves a second chance to do something that he loves to do, and has great skills. I don’t think that Vick will do this stuff again. Let him become a productive member of society again.

  5. D. Roberts (Virginia) says:

    Dang right he deserves to play. Put it like this, what’s the difference from what he did and all these hunting clubs. These guys go coon hunting. They train their dogs to tree a coon, the hunter shoots the coon out of tree, and it doesn’t kill it, the dogs then rips the coon to shreds, now that’s humane. Why? Are they going to eat it? Does it taste good? I’d say not. What did that coon do to them? Nothing. Just living in the wild. Minding their own business. Get real people. And by the way, how many people (adults and kids) have these pit bulls killed or critically injured over the years?? PETA, whatever.

  6. Hokeith says:

    Michael Vick does time (how many months?) in the federal pen for dogfighting, killing dogs, whatever.
    Donte Stallworth drives drunk and kills a pedestrian and gets 25 days.

    I don’t see the justice. Of course, Vick deserves a second chance in the NFL! After the Stallworth deal, it would appear that the first “chance” was UNJUSTIFIABLY taken from Vick.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. [...] crimes against animals should be and have been punished the same as those against people, with some making very good arguments.  I won’t go there, and I don’t know what NFL Commish Goodell will do in terms of [...]


Leave a Reply

2010-2011 Schedule

09/06 vs. Boise State (8pm ESPN)
09/11 vs. JMU
09/18 vs. ECU
09/25 @ Boston College
10/02 @ NC State
10/09 vs. Central Michigan
10/16 vs. Wake Forest
10/23 vs. Duke
11/04 vs. Georgia Tech (7:30pm, ESPN)
11/13 @ North Carolina
11/20 @ Miami
11/27 vs. Virginia
12/04 ACC Championship Game

Photos on flickr

Polls

How will the Hokies do in 2010?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...